The Contradiction of Healing

Why we cannot keep living against nature and expect our bodies to adapt

I recently shifted time zones and climates quite drastically. My body went through a period of adjustment, I felt run down, and a viral infection followed. As an Ayurvedic practitioner, I looked at how the infection was expressing itself and, with what I had available, used a natural approach to manage the symptoms while nourishing and supporting my body. My training also means I know what to watch for and when I would seek further medical care.

I was not particularly worried about how the infection would progress. The people around me, however, were. Their concern, and their suggestions of allopathic intervention, got me thinking. Why do we tend to become so fearful of our body’s response? Why do we place so much emphasis on relieving symptoms, as though making them disappear is the same as healing? Symptom-relieving medication can be important, and sometimes necessary. But symptom relief and supporting the body’s recovery are not always the same thing.

That experience also made me think about something I see in my work all the time.

There is a contradiction in the way many of us approach healing. We want our digestion to improve, our hormones to settle, our nervous system to calm and our energy to return. And we want all of it without changing the life that wore those things down.

We want to feel better so we can go back to doing everything exactly as we did before.

I see this especially with a young college student I work with, who seems to catch one thing after another. She recently told me she had slept for only four hours the night before a trip, despite already having a sore throat. The pattern is understandable. It’s college. It’s busy, active, and life feels largely experimental.

She recovers from one infection, starts feeling better, and before long she is dealing with something else. The focus tends to land on the illness itself, the infection or the inflammation. But I become equally interested in what is happening in the background.

From an Ayurvedic perspective, I pay particular attention to Vata, which governs movement in the body and mind and is sensitive to irregularity. In an overstimulating environment, disrupted sleep, inconsistent meals and constant activity can aggravate Vata and place additional strain on our capacity to maintain wellbeing and recover. This does not mean that a Vata imbalance causes viral or bacterial infections. It means that the conditions in which we live matter, and that proper sleep, rest, regular nourishment and a steadier daily rhythm can support the body’s resilience.

Yet there is often an expectation that we should take part in everything, accommodate every commitment and keep the same pace as everyone around us. This young woman believes that because she is in college, she has to experience everything it offers. But at what cost?

I understand that desire. There is so much we want to experience. She is not wrong to want it all. But her body has its own capacity, and learning to recognise it is part of understanding our nature. Sometimes the demands we place on ourselves simply exceed the resources available to meet them.

This, more than anything, is why I wanted to write this piece.

When results do not arrive, we often conclude that Ayurveda does not work, that it is too restrictive, that it does not fit our lives. But I think the more honest question is: are we conscious of what we fit into our lives?

The conditioning behind productivity

We have inherited a very particular idea of a successful life. Productivity, efficiency, consistency and achievement have become the measures of our worth. We organise our time around deadlines and targets, and we expect to deliver the same level of performance whatever our circumstances.

This has become so familiar that we rarely question it. We expect to wake with the same energy every morning, stay sharp all day, remain available to everyone, run our households and maintain our relationships. Somewhere in all of that, we are also expected to find time to look after our health, which tends to be the least of our priorities. Being busy has become associated with being valuable, while rest brings guilt or the feeling of falling behind.

That relationship with productivity shapes how we perceive our bodies. When we are tired, we look for something to give us energy. When we cannot sleep, we look for something to help us sleep. When digestion is irregular, we look for something to stimulate it. We become experts at managing the consequences of our days without examining the days themselves.

Over time, compensating becomes part of our identity. We learn to function on too little rest, irregular meals, constant stimulation and almost no time to process our experience. We push through physical signals because something else always needs our attention.

Eventually, we can lose the ability to recognise what our natural state of wellbeing feels like.

I learned something about this from a friend, about twenty years ago. I was not yet an Ayurvedic practitioner. I was a homeopath, and like many people, I was looking for the right tincture or remedy for quick relief. My friend was trying to quit smoking, and to do that she also had to stop drinking, because one set off the other. When I asked her how she felt a few weeks in, she described something I have never forgotten.

She said: “It’s like this, you live in a kind of mediocre feeling, always a little bit meh, and you decide that this is simply normal. It’s the best you can do.”

After she stopped smoking and drinking, the bar had gone way up. She felt alive and present, and she had not known that level of daily energy even existed.

That is what I mean about our capacity. Often we are not aware of the habits contributing to how we feel, so we never question the ways we compensate for them. How much of what we consider normal is really conditioning we have adapted to?

Life operates through rhythms

One of the foundations of Ayurveda is understanding life through its relationship with nature. The human body exists within the same world that governs the seasons, the cycles of the sun and moon, the changing qualities of the elements and the rhythms of growth and transformation. Our physiology responds to all of it.

We have circadian rhythms that shape our sleep, metabolism, hormones and cellular repair. Appetite, digestion and energy also shift with the season, our age, our constitution and our stage of life.

Yet many of us organise our lives around a fixed expectation of output. We keep the same pace in every season and treat rest as something to be earned once everything else is done.

Nature does not run on uninterrupted output. There are periods of growth, activity, nourishment, conservation, elimination and renewal, and the same principle of change exists within our bodies. Simply observe the trees and plants in each season. Cyclical living asks us to notice these rhythms and see how our choices interact with them.

Women are not meant to run on a flat line

This becomes particularly relevant when we look at women’s physiology. The idea of productivity we inherited was built around a 24-hour pattern: the same energy and output every day. A woman’s physiology does not always follow that pattern.

If you have a menstrual cycle, hormonal changes throughout the month can influence your energy, mood, concentration and capacity. Your productivity isn’t necessarily static. It can flow and change. Rather than overriding those shifts, you can learn to recognise the kind of energy you experience during each phase and consider how to work with it.

For example, during menstruation your body requires rest and release. In Ayurveda this is a time when downward-moving energy is active, and is best supported by slowing down. This is when rest IS your productivity, and it is real work.

After the bleed is the time when energy and curiosity rise. Productivity is to start things, plan and learn. And around ovulation the energy turns completely outward. Often the time for meetings, visibility, connection and collaboration.

The premenstrual week is when energy turns inward again. A natural slowing down, and time to finish, edit, simplify projects, and set boundaries of what gets your energy.

One week you may be running meetings and showing up in public. Next, your creativity and output look different, and that is not a failure. It is the cycle doing what it does.

Cycles vary, and not every woman has a regular one. Some experience significant changes throughout the month, while others notice very little difference. Treat this as a map for noticing rather than a rulebook.

A woman who plans her whole month as though she will feel the same on day 2 as on day 15 may find herself working against her own physiology, and blaming herself when her energy or concentration does not cooperate.

Learning your own cycle gives you another form of information you can use to plan your work, your relationships and your rest. It allows you to take your changing needs into consideration when making decisions about how you spend your time.

Rhythm first, then the work

Most often than not it all comes to how we manage our time. This is where I often meet resistance. Many people find Ayurveda rigid. “I try to do the routine, but how am I supposed to when I have this or that to do?” And one I hear constantly: “I don’t have time to eat in the afternoon or evening.”

One client works from home, with back-to-back calls throughout the day. She finds there is simply no space left to eat within the Ayurvedic dinner window. When we discuss introducing a more consistent routine, the answer is that there isn’t enough time.

This is where I keep returning to one question: how have we organised our lives to the point where looking after our basic physiological needs has become an extra task we struggle to fit in?

The order is backwards. You are not trying to make your body convenient for your work. You are making your work convenient for your body. Because she works from home, she has some freedom to build her working day around her meals, her rest and her personal care. Anchor the rhythm first, then fit the tasks into the pockets that remain.

This is also a better route to productivity. Our capacity to work, think, create and engage with others depends on how well we nourish and replenish ourselves. When we keep compromising those foundations, we eventually compromise the very capacity we are trying so hard to maintain.

I think this is also where society has shaped us most. The nine-to-five leaves a very narrow window for self-care, and we have grown so used to demands that run against our nature that we rarely notice them. More people are now leaving the office to work from home, and perhaps that model is slowly loosening. But the conditioning runs deep. Given the freedom, many of us simply rebuild the same pattern on our own, and keep disconnecting from our inner wisdom. But the body does not stop keeping score just because we stop listening. It keeps responding to the conditions we create.

The body does not stop responding to the conditions we create just because we stop listening.

Your body is an ecosystem

The human microbiome is one of the clearest examples of how connected we are. We carry trillions of microorganisms, particularly in the digestive tract, and they take part in digestion, metabolism and immune function. Their composition and activity respond to the environment we create: what we eat, how we sleep, our stress, our medications and our movement. In other words, the microbiome adapts to its environment, just as we do.

The same is true of digestion as a whole. We tend to ask which food or supplement is the problem. But what is happening in our nervous system when we sit down to eat? Are we eating at regular intervals, with enough time, or are we answering messages and rushing to the next commitment?

Digestion involves the nervous system, digestive secretions, gut motility and microbial activity working together. The environment in which we eat is also part of that relationship. The same interconnectedness applies to sleep, hormones and stress regulation. Seeing these relationships changes the questions we ask when something goes wrong.

Ayurveda asks us to examine the conditions we create

Ayurveda gives us a framework for understanding these relationships through the five elements, the three doshas, the qualities of nature and individual constitution. It looks at the relationship between a person and their environment, and at how food, digestion, routines, seasons, the senses and the mind shape the body.

Agni, often translated as digestive fire, is a good example. It is more than digesting food. It represents our capacity to transform and assimilate what we take in, physically and, in the broader philosophy, experientially.

This is also why Ayurvedic recommendations applied without understanding can become a problem. What supports one person may not suit another, and the same person’s needs change with age, constitution, health, environment and stage of life.

Herbs, dietary changes and body therapies are valuable. But they cannot compensate indefinitely for the conditions we keep recreating. This is why Ayurveda places so much importance on Dinacharya, the daily routine, and Ritucharya, the seasonal routine. They are about arranging our lives in relationship with the cycles that shape our wellbeing.

The mind behind the habits

Our habits come from how we think. The beliefs we inherit, the environments we grew up in and what we learned about being successful, responsible and worthy. Some of these patterns are so ingrained that we no longer see them as choices.

We may work beyond our capacity because we associate productivity with security. We may ignore hunger because everything else seems more important. We may struggle to rest because stillness brings up thoughts and feelings we have learned to avoid. We may reach for another protocol because taking action feels more familiar than looking at the life that keeps requiring it.

This is where the philosophy of Ayurveda becomes so relevant. It invites us to examine how we perceive and relate to the world. That is why I emphasise understanding the philosophy before moving into practical application. Recognising your constitution and your patterns of imbalance requires an interest in the relationship between your thoughts, behaviours, physical experience and surroundings.

This is one of the harder parts of healing. It asks us to question some of the behaviours and beliefs that have shaped our identity.

What does it mean to live in accordance with your nature?

Living in accordance with nature does not mean abandoning your work, leaving modern society or adopting an idealised version of traditional life. It means understanding the natural processes that influence us and considering how our choices interact with them.

It means recognising that our bodies have needs, that those needs change, and that our capacity depends on the conditions in which we live. Our relationship with food goes beyond nutrition, our relationship with movement goes beyond performance, and our relationship with rest goes beyond hours slept.

And it is worth saying plainly that not everyone has the freedom to restructure their life. Some of us are caring for children or parents, working fixed shifts or carrying financial pressure. This is not about perfection or blame. A single regular meal, a protected hour of rest or an earlier bedtime still counts. Small shifts in rhythm add up.

You do not need to believe in Ayurveda for these relationships to exist. The human body is part of nature, and its processes keep responding to the environment in which it lives.

We can spend years searching for ways to make our bodies adapt to the lives we have built. Or we can become curious about the story behind our patterns. What are the beliefs and expectations we keep upholding even when our bodies are telling us something different? And what might become possible if we made decisions with a deeper understanding of our own nature?

This, to me, is where the study of Ayurveda begins. It begins with an interest in life itself, in the intelligence that governs it and in our responsibility to understand the conditions in which that intelligence can express itself.

Healing also involves reconsidering the way we live, and that conversation deserves much more of our attention.

One small thing to try this week: Notice one place where you override a signal from your body, such as skipping a meal, pushing past tiredness or ignoring a need to rest. You do not have to change anything yet. Just notice what you are asking yourself to ignore.